No, you did not mistakenly pick up a legal journal with an article written for attorneys about the disolution of married couples. However, we will discuss some similarities between marriage and employment within the context of leadership and best practices recruiting.
Nothing is static. Things are in constant motion. Employees change and companies change ... sometimes destroying the employee-employer relationship.
When it is determined that critical talent is holding the company back, a change must be made.
When changing critical talent out, does it always have to be an uncomfortable event that results in a broken relationship?
This event is inevitable. What are you doing about it?
Professionals have goals, ambitions and a personal life to juggle. The challenges and rewards, which attracted the professional to originally join your company, may no longer apply as the employees career has developed. Companies have goals, objectives and the responsibility to deliver value to their stakeholders.
When the employer hired the professional, enough of the employees goals and the employers goals intersected to make for the foundation of a good employer/employee relationship.
As time has gone on, the employee has developed more experience and has redefined career objectives. The companys growth objective may be through existing market penetration, the penetration of new markets, acquisitions or something else.
Are the goals of employee and employer still intersecting?
Has the employer reached a point where the company must keep growing in order to remain relevant and remain in business? What direction will deliver needed growth? Once the employer has determined a direction forgrowth, what changes are needed?
What got the company to this point may not be what the company needs to get to the next level. From the perspective of critical talent, what got the company to this point may have included the efforts of some extremely dedicated employees who have earned the employers loyalty. While the loyalty is well deserved, it can cause the employer to evaluate the employees future abilities and contributions through clouded lenses. The evaluation should be based upon the critical employees potential and not based on the critical employees list of past accomplishments. Can this person get you where you need to go?
Intellectually, employers find the answer to be easy. They know when a critical employee has maximized their ability to contribute. Sometimes, it is a matter of additional training or an adjustment in responsibilities. In other cases, no amount of training or different responsibilities will resolve the issue. Clearly, the employee no longer fits the company. With that revelation comes the difficulty of an emotional conclusion: How can we possibly move them out after all of the loyalty they have given us.
It is a challenging dilemma.
What is the likely result of a critical employee remaining under a mis-fitting scenario?
Unhappy critical employee
Critical talent who is not challenged and unable to pursue career development
An employer who is less competitive and less productive
An employer with a critical employee viewed by peers as under-performing
Many employers find their growth to be stunted at this point. It can become a most difficult barrier for companies to overcome. Employers who have successfully faced this have decisively made a change. Whether the change takes the form of a brutal termination or some type of amicable separation, they all fall under the general classification of employment divorce.
Websters Dictionary defines divorce as to end a marriage and to make separate. This definition does not include or suggest that a failure has occurred. It does not point blame. It does not involve alimony. There is no mention of children or mothers-in-law. Nothing needs to be split-up.
If we agree that businesses and people must both continually develop, then we must also agree that both wont necessarily develop in the same direction. Bad employment divorces leave deep emotional scars with no one as the winner.
What is the likely result of a good employment divorce?
New opportunity for the talent to take on new challenges and career development
Lasting appreciation by the talent toward the previous employer for professional treatment and care during the employment divorce
Opportunity for the employer to solely focus on acquiring new critical talent without needing to address any untidy departing employee issues
Likelihood that the departing talent could become an ally working within the industry
Possibility that the departing employee could some day return to the employer in a more advanced role and delivering renewed value
On a personal note, I have observed good employment divorces only a few times and wish it were more common. It is impressive when both parties openly speak well of the other with genuine respect. Both parties have moved forward and find they are in a better place through growth and related changes in the marketplace.
As was mentioned at the top of this discussion,nothing is static. With the embracing of change comes the anticipation that talent will change, as well. Accepting that a transition is a part of growth, there comes a time when the employer must acquire talent that better fits the next step and the employee is better suited to take on a new role for a new employer. With communication and professionalism, the event can be a win-win. It makes you ask, Why doesnt this happen more often?
You can get there from here. Good divorces can be a very productive solution to an employment relationship that is no longer delivering the value.
About Boxwood Search
There is a battle for senior level talent. A great hire can make a long term positive impact and a failed hire can prove to be very expensive. How does a company recruit and hire the right talent? It is more than just networking within the community of friends and business associates. It requires focusing on results through a process oriented approach. We are committed to reaching a successful outcome. Our recruitment method has repeatedly proven to deliver very qualified senior talent.
We exclusively represent employers in the marketplace as a dedicated resource and discrete trusted advisor. Through original research and industry contacts, we will target qualified candidates and motivate them to consider the opportunity.
We will screen candidates against key criteria, analyze technical fit along with cultural fit, interview, contact references and present our recommendations. Upon making the offer, we are the employers advocate and an active participant in communicating with the candidate until offer acceptance has been secured. Results are guaranteed.